It depends. Are you looking for cheaper options or premium products? With Gelato print services, you may get lower product prices but not consistently high quality because all Gelato products are outsourced to third-party suppliers that vary in terms of prices and quality.

Printful prices can be higher for certain products, but Printful’s entire product catalog is fulfilled by in-house professionals or a handful of trusted partners. This means you get reliable quality, predictable fulfillment costs, 24/7 customer support, and consistent branding options like packing slips and tracking pages for all your orders.

It depends. There are many ways to measure the sustainability aspects of a print-on-demand company.

One metric that can be used to compare Printful and Gelato is the number of products fulfilled in the same region. More than 85% of the Gelato print-on-demand products are fulfilled locally, while Printful’s locally fulfilled product share is around 84%.

While there is a difference, it’s not significant enough to consider Printful or Gelato the more eco-friendly print-on-demand company.

Both Gelato and Printful are print-on-demand service providers, but Printful owns and controls the entire production process, while Gelato simply connects sellers to printing partners.

As a result, Printful needs fewer fulfillment centers and prints high-quality products in-house, which creates a consistent customer experience no matter where your buyers are.

Gelato is a network that acts as a middleman between printing partners and the customer. Outsourcing the production to other suppliers allows the company to keep costs low, but it also means there’s little consistency in Gelato print quality control.

Yes, Printful’s product catalog has 457 custom products, while the Gelato print-on-demand catalog assortment includes around 130–150 products.

Printful also has more product categories than Gelato. While both companies fulfill items like wall art and t-shirts, Printful also has an extensive home & living collection, including custom products like blankets, candles, towels, yoga mats, etc.

The Gelato print-on-demand product catalog also doesn’t include hats, footwear, drinkware, or pet products. Even in the most popular categories of customizable products (t-shirts, hoodies, wall art, etc.), Gelato has fewer products than Printful.

Yes and no. There are currently 24 direct Printful integrations, while Gelato only integrates with 6 ecommerce platforms or marketplaces.

At the same time, Gelato works with Order Desk, which allows print-on-demand store owners to streamline their orders and connect with 275+ ecommerce services.

Having an additional step in your order fulfillment flow means additional investment and hassle.

If you want a simpler flow where your orders are fulfilled automatically at no added cost, Printful is the right choice for you. But if you already have a store on a platform that Printful doesn’t connect to, you may have an easier time using Gelato.

Yes, when it comes to things like packing slips and order tracking. When it comes to product branding like inside labels, Printful and Gelato have equivalent options for both DTG and embroidery techniques.

Printful’s packaging customization options are both more varied and more accessible than Gelato’s. All Printful products come in white-label packaging by default, but you can create and arrange for custom packaging or pack-ins as a paid option. But if that’s too difficult, you can put a custom message on your packing slips and add branding to your order tracking page, both free of charge.

Gelato’s custom packaging options are limited to packaging inserts and branded labels, which are both paid options.

Absolutely! By teaming up with Printful, you get high-quality products printed with one partner, by one team, under one roof.